PaycheckPlain
Home › Pay stub checker

Pay stub checker

Updated Sep 28, 2026 · 2026 IRS and Social Security figures · how we calculate

Paycheck smaller than you expected, or a line on your stub you can't explain? Pick your state, enter your pay and W-4 details, then open Check my pay stub and type the amounts from your stub. Each line is compared with the rules, and any difference comes with the most likely reason.

Or open any state paycheck calculator and use the "Check my pay stub" section under the form. Nothing you type leaves your browser.

What the checker looks at

Example

A $60,000 salary paid every two weeks, single: the rules give $193.08 of federal income tax. Suppose the stub shows $337.88. The checker reports:

Federal income tax matches if the W-4 Step 2 box is checked (two jobs, or married and both work). Check the W-4 your employer has on file.

That's the W-4 Step 2 box - meant for two jobs or two working spouses. If it doesn't apply to you, a new W-4 fixes it.

How to read your pay stub

Using year-to-date totals

The YTD column adds up every paycheck so far this year. It's the quickest way to check two things: whether Social Security has stopped (it should once YTD Social Security wages reach $184,500, taking at most $11,439.00 for the year), and whether Additional Medicare has started (once YTD Medicare wages pass $200,000). If you changed jobs this year, each employer counts from zero, so both can restart at the new job.

Why taxable wages on the stub are lower than gross

Stubs often show separate wage figures for federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare. Federal taxable wages leave out a traditional 401(k) or 403(b) and pre-tax (section 125) health, dental, vision and HSA deductions. Social Security and Medicare wages leave out only the section 125 deductions - a 401(k) is still taxed for Social Security and Medicare. Enter your 401(k) percentage and pre-tax benefits in the calculator so the expected amounts use the same wages as your stub.

Why your paycheck doesn't match an online paycheck calculator

Most paycheck calculators, ours included, open on simple assumptions: a full pay period, a W-4 with nothing but a filing status, no 401(k) or health deductions, and no city tax. Your stub reflects your real setup, so a gap usually means one of these assumptions doesn't fit you:

Enter those details in the calculator and use Check my pay stub: it compares each line and names the setting that reproduces your stub.

If something still doesn't match

First make sure the details above match your W-4 and your state's withholding form - most differences come from there. Then check for a bonus or commission in that paycheck (the bonus tax calculator shows how it's withheld). If a line is still off by more than a few dollars, ask your payroll team; mistakes happen and are easiest to fix early. Our W-4 guide explains each W-4 step.

What's that line on my stub?

Plain explanations of state deductions, with how to check each one: WA Cares Fund · CA SDI · NY PFL and disability (SDI) · NJ SDI and FLI · MA PFML · Colorado FAMLI · Paid Leave Oregon and transit tax · PA local EIT and LST · Ohio city income tax.

Check your own paycheck

Your state's paycheck calculator · W-4 guide

Sources

Questions

How do I know if my paycheck is right?

Compare each line of your stub with what the tax rules say for your pay, W-4 and state form. The checker does it line by line and explains any difference.

Why is my federal withholding higher than expected?

Most often the W-4 Step 2 box is checked, your filing status on file is different, you asked for extra withholding, or the paycheck includes a bonus.

Why doesn't my paycheck match the paycheck calculator?

Usually because the calculator is set up differently from your payroll: pre-tax deductions, W-4 choices, a partial pay period, a bonus, or a state or city tax that isn't entered. Enter the same details and the checker points to the line that differs.

Why doesn't my W-2 match my last pay stub?

Box 1 of the W-2 is year-to-date gross pay minus a traditional 401(k) and pre-tax (section 125) benefits, so it's lower than the gross on your stub. Boxes 3 and 5 (Social Security and Medicare wages) leave out only the section 125 benefits, and box 3 stops at the Social Security wage base.

Why is Social Security not 6.2% of my gross?

Pre-tax health, dental and vision premiums through a cafeteria plan are taken off first. A 401(k) is not - Social Security applies to it.